Understanding the Difference Between an Employee and an Independent Contractor
Determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor is crucial and can be complex. Here’s a simplified guide based on court decisions over the years, highlighting the major factors to consider.
Control:
- Employee: An employer controls what, where, how, and when the work is done.
- Independent Contractor: Contractors have more freedom to decide how they complete their work, usually based on the contract terms.
Integration in the Business:
- Employee: Employees are integrated into the business, might wear a company uniform, and receive training from the employer.
- Independent Contractor: Contractors operate independently, working on specific contracts without integrating into the payer’s business.
Risk:
- Employee: Takes no commercial risks as the employer is responsible for any legal liabilities or defects in the work.
- Independent Contractor: Bears the risk of legal liabilities and defects in their work.
Payment:
- Employee: Paid a salary, hourly rate, piecemeal rate, or commission, regardless of the business outcome.
- Independent Contractor: Paid for achieving a specific result, often outlined in a quote.
Equipment, Tools, and Assets:
- Employee: Typically provided by the employer or compensated for by the employer.
- Independent Contractor: Must provide their own equipment and tools without reimbursement.
Expenses:
- Employee: Often reimbursed for job-related expenses.
- Independent Contractor: Covers their own expenses without reimbursement.
Delegation:
- Employee: Must personally perform the work.
- Independent Contractor: Can delegate tasks to others, such as subcontractors.
Appointment and Termination:
- Employee: Usually hired through job ads or recruitment agencies and can be dismissed according to employment laws.
- Independent Contractor: Hired to complete specific tasks and cannot usually be terminated without penalty unless they breach contract terms.
For further clarification or advice, contact Tax Ideas Accountants & Advisers at
+61 2 83181545 or book an appointment directly through our live calendar.
